05 May 2014

Cinco De Mayo Flag T-Shirt Ban, Or When Did Patriotism Become a BAD Thing?


Everyone knows that the 5th of May is celebrated by those of Mexican descent, and nobody should have a problem with that. To celebrate one's heritage is to honor where you came from and the sacrifices your ancestors made to get you to where you are. I am a very proud Irishman myself, even with all the negative stereotypes involved with that. To understand where this post is going, you need a little background into the history of the Cinco de Mayo holiday, especially in America.


Spanish for “fifth of May,” Cinco de Mayo is a celebration held in the United States and Mexico, most notably in the Mexican state of Puebla, obviously on the 5th of May. Originating in the American West in communities of Mexican descent to commemorate the cause of freedom and democracy, today the date is a celebration of Mexican heritage and pride. In Puebla, the day commemorates the Mexican Army's unlikely victory over vastly superior French forces on 5 MAY 1862.


Cinco de Mayo has its roots in the French occupation of Mexico, which took place in the aftermath of the Mexican-American War of 1846-48, the Mexican Civil War of 1858, and the 1860 Reform Wars. These wars left the Mexican Treasury nearly bankrupt. In July of 1862, Mexican President Benito Juarez declared a two-year moratorium on all foreign debt payments, prompting Great Britain, France, and Spain to send fleets to Veracruz. The Spanish and English negotiated with the Mexican government and sent their fleets home.


The French, ruled by Napolean III at the time, were unmollified. Late in 1861, seeking to establish a Latin empire favorable to French interests, an 8,000 strong French force stormed ashore at Veracruz, encountering little meaningful resistance and sending the Mexican government into retreat. Moving towards Mexico City from Veracruz, the French suffered a decisive, though relatively short-lived, defeat at the hands of an ill-equipped and much smaller Mexican Army of 4,500 men at the forts of Loreto and Guadalupe, near Puebla.


The American Cinco de Mayo celebration originated in communities of Mexican descent in the American West, Southwest, and Northwest in the 1860s. Mexicans and Latinos living in California during the American Civil War are credited with being the first to celebrate Cinco de Mayo in the United States. It grew in popularity and evolved into a celebration of Mexican culture and heritage, first in areas with large Mexican-American populations, like Los Angeles, Chicago, and Houston. Eventually it expanded across the United States. On June 7, 2005, the U.S. Congress issued a Concurrent Resolution calling on the President of the United States to issue a proclamation calling upon the people of the United States to observe Cinco de Mayo with appropriate ceremonies and activities.


In the United States Cinco de Mayo has taken on a significance beyond that in Mexico. To celebrate, many display Cinco de Mayo banners while school districts hold special events to educate pupils about its historical significance. Special events and celebrations highlight Mexican culture, especially in its music and regional dancing. Examples include baile folklórico and mariachi demonstrations held annually at the Plaza del Pueblo de Los Angeles, near Olvera Street. Commercial interests in the United States have capitalized on the celebration, advertising Mexican products and services, with an emphasis on beverages, foods, and music.


"Public memory of the Cinco de Mayo was socially, and deliberately, constructed during the American Civil War by Latinos responding to events and changes around them," says historian David E. Hayes-Bautista. "The Cinco de Mayo is not, in its origins, a Mexican holiday at all but rather an American one, created by Latinos in California in the middle of the 19th century. (David E. Hayes-Bautista, "El Cinco de Mayo: An American Tradition (2011) p 5)


I think it's time for me to reiterate that there is nothing wrong with celebrating your heritage. I've detailed in other posts how I believe it is wrong to place your heritage before your American citizenry, and how multiculturalism is destroying this nation, formerly known as “the great melting-pot” of the world. The American culture, into which all immigrants are supposed to assimilate, is being subsumed by those who refuse to do just that – assimilate.


That being said, can someone explain how and why it became a bad thing to celebrate being an American here in AMERICA?! Late in February of this year, a federal court ruled that a high school in California is not violating the civil rights of patriotic students by banning them from wearing American Flag t-shirts on Cinco de Mayo. The school's reasoning for the ban – fears of “racial violence,” saying they might enflame Latino students celebrating today.


I understand that the school has a history of gang fights and racial tension, but are the administrators there really stupid enough to believe that it's all one way? Let's not mention that there isn't even an American “race.” Why, then, is it considered okay for Latinos to celebrate their heritage, and what is essentially an American “holiday,” but not for others to celebrate their own heritage? Did no one consider that celebrating Cinco de Mayo might just “enflame” racial tensions the other way?


My family has a saying: “If you do for one, you do for all.” It's something I've tried to follow, with varying success, for my entire life. If you apply that logic to the American Flag t-shirt ban, what the school should have done is ban all ethnic celebrations today, or any day for that matter. It's not something in which I'm truly in favor, but there's no excuse for banning one display of patriotism, while permitting another display.


It's beyond disgusting that a school, and a federal court, IN AMERICA, think that it's somehow appropriate to essentially stifle American citizens' Right to Free Speech for fear of offending others. It's beyond offensive that a display of patriotism for the nation in which we live is somehow considered inflammatory in the country in which we live.


Patriotism is not, nor should it ever be considered, a BAD THING, nor should it be discouraged. Indeed, it should be readily and heartily encouraged. Patriotism got us through the Revolution, World War 2, and September 11th, just to name a few. Patriotism is still a primary motivator for those who join our all-volunteer armed forces. I don't think anyone can truly say that those are bad things for America. ~ Hunter

No comments:

Post a Comment